The hidden costs of tool sprawl: An SRE’s guide to observability consolidation

Why the big push for consolidation? While some observability teams follow a best-of-breed tool strategy, having a smorgasbord of tools isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. Here are some of the hidden costs of tool sprawl:

1. Cognitive overload: Switching between multiple tools during an incident can slow down your response time and increase the chance of missing critical information.

2. Training overhead: Onboarding new team members becomes a Herculean task when they need to learn a dozen different tools.

3. Integration nightmares: Getting all your tools to play nicely together can be like herding cats — frustrating and often futile.

4. Budget bloat: Multiple tool licenses and maintenance costs can quickly eat into your budget, leaving less room for innovation. Cost-effective observability tools allow you to monitor your entire environment rather than make you pick and choose what to omit.

Now, before you rush off to slash and burn your tool stack, it’s worth noting that consolidation isn’t without its challenges and requires organizational commitment. The practitioner survey (mentioned above) highlighted some key hurdles:

• Conflicting requirements (53%): Different teams often have different needs, making it tricky to find a one-size-fits-all solution.

• Competing priorities (50%): With so many fires to put out, finding time for consolidation can feel like a luxury.

• Resource constraints (40%): Implementing a new, consolidated solution often requires an upfront investment in time and resources.

• Tool attachment (37%): Teams can be surprisingly attached to their favorite tools, making change management a delicate dance.

Despite these challenges, the benefits of consolidation are too significant to ignore. Here are some practical steps you can take to streamline your observability toolkit:

1. Audit your current toolset: Start by mapping out all the tools you’re currently using and their primary functions. Identify areas of overlap and gaps in coverage.

2. Define your must-haves: Work with all stakeholders to identify the non-negotiable features and capabilities your consolidated solution must have.

3. Prioritize integration: Look for solutions that are flexible and play well with others. The ability to integrate with your existing tech stack can make the transition much smoother.

4. Consider open standards and OpenTelemetry: As the second fastest growing project in the Cloud Native Computing Foundation (CNCF) ecosystem, many SRE teams believe that OpenTelemetry will be the de facto standard for observability data in the near future. UsingOpenTelemetry minimizes vendor lock-in and can help teams scale seamlessly in the long term giving them the freedom to choose the right backend tool. 

5. Champion change management: Don’t underestimate the human element. Involve team members in the decision-making process and provide ample training and support during the transition.

6. Start small: Consider a phased approach, starting with consolidating tools in one area (e.g., log management) before tackling the entire observability stack.

7. Leverage unified platforms: Consider platforms that offer a suite of integrated tools. For example, Elastic Observability provides logs, metrics, and application performance monitoring (APM) in a single, unified solution, significantly reducing tool sprawl.

The light at the end of the tunnel

While the journey to consolidation may seem daunting, the payoff can be substantial. SREs who have successfully consolidated their tools report benefits like:

• Faster incident response times

• Improved cross-team collaboration

• Reduced toil in day-to-day operations

• More time for innovation and system improvements

Remember, the goal isn’t to have the fewest tools possible, but to have the right tools that work together seamlessly to support your observability needs. By thoughtfully consolidating your toolkit, you’re not just reducing costs — you’re paving the way for a more efficient, more effective, and less stressful SRE practice.

So, the next time you find yourself juggling multiple tools in the wee hours of the morning, remember: there’s a better way. Your future self (and your sleep schedule) will thank you for taking the steps toward a more consolidated, manageable observability approach.

Read the full report: The state of observability in 2024: A practitioner perspective.

The release and timing of any features or functionality described in this post remain at Elastic’s sole discretion. Any features or functionality not currently available may not be delivered on time or at all.